Of Sound and Flavour – Revisiting the Notion of Material for the Cultural Sociological Analysis of Art Domains

Abstract

This article proposes a possible path for a materialist cultural sociology of art, focusing on the dynamics of art(s) domains and harnessing Adorno’s dialectical notion of material anew. I seek to establish links between dynamics of the arts domains and the fostering of specific modes of engagement with them – and, potentially, stances in other domains of life. I argue that a return to Adorno’s notion of (musical) material allows for such connections to be made: the ‘material’ is where the dynamics of the specific arts domains are inscribed; but it is also what is engaged with – by composers and artists as well as by interpreters, performers and publics. A dialectical material lens seems well suited for the critical study of the dynamic of arts domains in the 20th and 21st centuries, given the multiple artistic ‘breaks’ proclaimed. Focusing on some well-known movements in music and cuisine which sought to ‘emancipate’, ‘democratise’, and ‘diversify’ sounds and flavours, I analyse the processes through which they produced sound and flavour anew. I suggest that sounds and flavours themselves have become the carriers of logics relevant to music and cuisine, and that they have come to imperiously command modes of commitment (from composers and chefs, performers, listeners and diners alike) that evince specific stances. Through this necessarily sketchy survey, I provide indications that broader, cross-cutting cultural dynamics may be at stake. Overall, I seek to make clear what theoretical steps are afforded by the joint attention to materiality and the dynamic of art domains.

Bosch’s Brush: Imagination and Reality in 15th-Century Dutch

“…The objective of this research is to improve the knowledge of the social situations shown in Bosch's works by providing a contextual framework, thereby enabling a more nuanced interpretation of these occurrences. This enhances the linkage between art and sociology (Darmon, 2020). Comprehending this concept in depth is essential for examining the societal factors that influenced Bosch's artworks and their significance in the historical setting.…”

O feeling do rock: A Formação do Gosto nas Relações Organizadas de Vínculo entre músicos amadores e rock music

“…Hennion (2007) entende o gosto como uma atividade reflexiva, em que o indivíduo se envolve em um descobrir de um objeto que a ele se apresenta, de forma a se tornar ativamente passivo e se deixar levar pela apreciação deste. Ele chama a atenção para o foco que o sujeito articula ante a presença do objeto do seu gosto (Darmon, 2020), evidenciando uma coprodução situada entre estes (Paßmann & Schubert, 2020) que se dá justamente neste descobrir e se deixar ser descoberto (Hennion, 2007). Tal relação de coprodução leva ao desenvolvimento de um vínculo (Hennion, 2007), que, como destaca Gherardi (2009), tem em sua formação a incidência de julgamentos tácitos e estéticos.…”

Editorial Statement: Visions for Cultural Sociology in Uncertain Times

“…This is particularly the case within the sociology of the arts (e.g. Darmon, 2021). 1 Others still, understand culture as practice (e.g.…”