On selection of the optimal data time interval for real-time hydrological forecasting

Abstract

Abstract. With the advancement in modern telemetry and communication technologies, hydrological data can be collected with an increasingly higher sampling rate. An important issue deserving attention from the hydrological community is which suitable time interval of the model input data should be chosen in hydrological forecasting. Such a problem has long been recognised in the control engineering community but is a largely ignored topic in operational applications of hydrological forecasting. In this study, the intrinsic properties of rainfall-runoff data with different time intervals are first investigated from the perspectives of the sampling theorem and the information loss using the discrete wavelet transform tool. It is found that rainfall signals with very high sampling rates may not always improve the accuracy of rainfall-runoff modelling due to the catchment low-pass-filtering effect. To further investigate the impact of a data time interval in real-time forecasting, a real-time forecasting system is constructed by incorporating the probability distributed model (PDM) with a real-time updating scheme, the autoregressive moving-average (ARMA) model. Case studies are then carried out on four UK catchments with different concentration times for real-time flow forecasting using data with different time intervals of 15, 30, 45, 60, 90 and 120 min. A positive relation is found between the forecast lead time and the optimal choice of the data time interval, which is also highly dependent on the catchment concentration time. Finally, based on the conclusions from the case studies, a hypothetical pattern is proposed in threedimensional coordinates to describe the general impact of the data time interval and to provide implications of the selection of the optimal time interval in real-time hydrological forecasting. Although nowadays most operational hydrological systems still have low data sampling rates (daily or hourly), the future is that higher sampling rates will become more widespread, and there is an urgent need for hydrologists both in academia and in the field to realise the significance of the data time interval issue. It is important that more case studies in different catchments with various hydrological forecasting systems are explored in the future to further verify and improve the proposed hypothetical pattern.

Assessment of SMOS soil moisture retrieval parameters using tau–omega algorithms for soil moisture deficit estimation

“…The PDM has been widely applied throughout the world for runoff prediction and currently in use for both operational and design purposes (Bell and Moore, 1998). It is under the category of lumped rainfall-runoff model capable of representing a variety of catchment-scale hydrological behaviors and requires only rainfall and reference evapotranspiration (ETo) for discharge prediction (Liu and Han, 2013). The model conceptual structural work flow of PDM is depicted through Fig.…”

Influence of Changes of Catchment Permeability and Frequency of Rainfall on Critical Storm Duration in an Urbanized Catchment—A Case Study, Cracow, Poland

“…In reality, the time of concentration is correlated to different watershed parameters such as watershed area, main channel length, basin slope, soil type, and vegetation (roughness) [21]. In case of forecast of hydrological phenomena, the time of concentration significantly influences on tends of time interval [22]. Commonly the time of concentration is interpreted as critical storm duration (D kr ).…”

Interacting Effects of Precipitation and Potential Evapotranspiration Biases on Hydrological Modeling

“…The PDM is a conceptual rainfall‐runoff model with analytical and computational simplicity (Beven, 2012; Moore, 2007). Its soil moisture storage capacity is characterized by a simple probability distribution curve (Liu & Han, 2013). This model has been widely applied in the UK and other countries.…”