We present a simple model demonstrating that time-symmetric (advanced + retarded) relativistic interactions can account for statistical correlations violating the Bell inequalities while avoiding conspiracies as well as the commitment to instantaneous (direct space-like) influences. We provide an explicit statistical analysis of the model while highlighting some of the difficulties arising from retrocausal effects. Finally, we discuss how this account fits into the framework of Bell's theorem.
IntroductionIn his article 'Speakable and unspeakable in quantum mechanics' John S. Bell, discussing the implications of his seminal non-locality theorem [1-3] concludes For me then this is the real problem with quantum theory: the apparently essential conflict between any sharp formulation [of quantum theory] and fundamental relativity. That is to say, we have an apparent incompatibility, at the deepest level, between the two fundamental pillars of contemporary theory.. . . It may be that a real synthesis of quantum and relativity theories requires not just technical developments but radical conceptual renewal.[ In fact, Bell himself in a later publication [6] suggested that the GRW collapse theory may lend itself to a precise relativistic formulation, a feat that was indeed accomplished by Tumulka [7], albeit only in a non-interacting setting (but see [8] and references therein for further developments; see [9] for a critical discussion of Tumulka's model). Also, Lorentz invariant generalizations of Bohmian mechanics can be formulated, although for the price of introducing a preferred foliation of space-time (which, however, can be generated by a Lorentz invariant law and shown to be empirically undetectable [10]). All in all, the understanding that has grown over the last few years is that there is no incompatibility but a distinct tension between relativity and quantum non-locality and that this tension is not primarily characterized by the thread of superluminal signalling but, more subtly, by the fact that relativistic space-time-having no structure of absolute simultaneity and no objective temporal order between space-like separated eventsis not particularly hospitable to the kind of instantaneous influences that, according to Bell's theorem, the explanation of certain non-local correlations seems to require. (For a comprehensive discussion of this issue, see [11,12]; see [13] for a simple argument substantiating said tension.)In this paper, we want to discuss a possible route to alleviating the tension between relativity and non-locality by explaining non-local correlations as a result of interactions that are both retarded and advanced. Despite the technical and conceptual difficulties that come with advanced interactions, the hope associated with such models is that they could provide a complete physical account of quantum correlations while drawing exclusively on the resources of relativistic spacetime with particles interacting along their past and future light cones. In fact, it can be argued on the basis of t...