Transcription is conventionally believed to occur by passage of a mobile polymerase along a fixed template. Evidence for this model is derived almost entirely from material prepared using hypotonic salt concentrations. Studies on subnuclear structures isolated using hypertonic conditions, and more recently using conditions closer to the physiological, suggest an alternative. Transcription occurs as the template moves past a polymerase attached to a nucleoskeleton; this skeleton is the active site of transcription. Evidence for the two models is summarised. Much of it is consistent with the polymerase being attached and not freely diffusible. Some consequences of such a model are discussed.The accepted model for transcription contains three essential participants -the template, polymerase and nascent RNA [I, 21. Transcription is initiated by a diffusible polymerase binding to a promoter; the polymerase then processes along the DNA (Fig. 1 A). As knowledge has increased, other occasional participants have been added (e. g. transcription factors, topoisomerases) but not any other central players. Evidence for this model comes almost entirely from studies using hypotonic salt concentrations, largely because chromatin aggregates in physiological concentrations and so becomes difficult to use. In contrast, studies on preparations isolated using hyper-or iso-tonic salt concentrations suggest that active RNA polymerase is associated with a nucleoskeleton and is not freely diffusible. This nucleoskeleton is seen as the active site of RNA synthesis and transcription occurs by movement of DNA past the attachcd polymerase (Fig. 1 B).Ultimately models will be distinguished by reconstructing efficient transcription in vitro from purified constituents. Proof of the model involving an attached polymerase will require measurement ofits association constant for a skeleton. In the meantime, the two models can be distinguished operationally by determining whether the polymerase is freely diffusible or attached to a larger structure. Much evidence for the 'text-book' model is consistent with the alternative; this alternative has a number of important consequences and these are examined. Discussion centrcs on RNA polymerase 11, the enzyme that transcribes most eukaryotic genes, but applies equally to other polymerases.
ARTEFACTSStructure within isolated nuclei cannot be discussed sensibly without some consideration of problems caused by artefacts. They arise because nuclei and chromatin aggregate in physiological salt concentrations 131 ; therefore unphysiological conditions are almost invariably used. ControversyCorrespondence to P. R. Cook, Sir William Dunn School of Pathology, Universlty of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3RE. UK centres on whether structures seen In vitro are any more than isolation artefacts. RNA, DNA and protein, each concentrated in the nucleus at about 0.1 g/ml, might be expected to aggregate as soon as ion concentrations are altered. (For reviews of the controversy, see [4-61.) Nuclei are usually isol...