“…For the remaining cases, we may take the following, again as suggested by Jürgen Müller: for g = 5, 13, 25, 41 : G g = (C 4 × C 2 ) C 4 = SmallGroup (32,2) for g = 7, 16, 34 : G g = C 9 C 3 = SmallGroup (27,4) for g = 23 : G g = SL 2 (3) C 4 = SmallGroup(96,66) Again, we can appeal to Breuer's catalog to see that G g is a subgroup of Mod(S g ), and the same character theory argument shows that these groups are not subgroups of SO (5), nor do they have a subgroup of index 2 in SO (4). By the theorem of Mecchia-Zimmermann, we then have than these G g do not lie in Diff + (S 4 ).…”