On the Outskirts of Physics: Eva von Bahr as an Outsider Within in Early 20th Century Swedish Experimental Physics

Abstract

Eva von Bahr (1874–1962) got her doctorate in experimental physics at the Physics Institute at Uppsala University in 1908. Subsequently she became the first woman assistant professor in physics in Sweden. In the face of many obstacles, she worked as a physicist for six years in Uppsala and Berlin. In 1914 she took a position as a school teacher. This article explores von Bahr’s trajectory through academic experimental physics. It is argued that network connections with male scientists enabled her work. Her associations were a mix between institutional relationships and informal connections, resulting in what is labeled a ‘hybrid of connections’. Furthermore it is argued that von Bahr became an ‘outsider within’ in academic experimental physics. Her connections created openings, but these coexisted with hindrances. It is argued that von Bahr oscillated between being an insider and an outsider which created a fractured identity. Her position and identity was a mix between membership and non‐membership. Through examining von Bahr’s career this article aims to bring together historical research on women in science and theoretical work in science studies. Furthermore, the article argues the analytical value of feminist perspectives on scientific collaborations as a way to a deeper understanding of the network structures of science.

Secrets and lies: “selective openness” in the apparatus of animal experimentation

“…They are in a complex situation, because they are representatives of the public at the same time as they are part of the apparatus. They are "outsiders within" (Wennerholm, 2009) A seemingly contradictory strategy is to stage animal experimentation by means of openness.…”

A Fractured Position in a Stable Partnership: Ebba Hult, Gerard De Geer, and Early Twentieth Century Swedish Geology

“…Their participation became gendered in similar fashions. The clearest example is the nation's first associate professor in experimental physics Eva von Bahr who after a promising start had to quit science before reaching an influential position (Wennerholm 2009).…”

The Entanglement of Gender and Physics

“…Insightful studies are available about outstanding female physicists such as the first female professor in Europe, the 18 th century physicist Laura Bassi (Ceranski, 1996;Findlen, 1993) or the 1963 Nobel Prize winner Maria Goeppert Meyer, who between her doctoral dissertation at Göttingen University, Germany, in 1930 and her appointment as full professor at the University of California at San Diego, USA, in 1960 worked for 30 years as a poorly paid 'volunteer' in theoretical nuclear physics and during that time developed her nuclear shell model (Moszkowski, 2006, Willisch, 2008. Other findings spotlight on less celebrated physicists such as the researcher in quantum chemistry Hertha Sponer, who from 1920s to the 1960s worked as professor at universities in Göttingen/Germany, Oslo/ Norway, and Durham/USA (Maushart, 1997;Tobies, 1996), or the first Swedish female assistant professor Eva von Bahr, a productive scientist in Uppsala and Berlin between 1908and 1914(Wennerholm, 2009. Furthermore, Byers and Williams (2006) edited a collection of 40 biographies of women who contributed to twentiethcentury physics.…”