LolO, a 2-oxoglutarate-dependent nonheme Fe oxygenase, catalyzes both the hydroxylation of 1-exo-acetamidopyrrolizidine (AcAP), a pathway intermediate in the biosynthesis of the loline alkaloids, and the cycloetherification of the resulting alcohol. We have prepared fluorinated AcAP analogues to aid in continued mechanistic investigation of the remarkable LolOcatalyzed cycloetherification step. LolO was able to hydroxylate 6,6-difluoro-AcAP (prepared from N,O-protected 4-oxoproline) and then cycloetherify the resulting alcohol, forming a difluorinated analogue of N-acetylnorloline and providing evidence for a cycloetherification mechanism involving a C(7) radical as opposed to a C(7) carbocation. By contrast, LolO was able to hydroxylate 7,7-difluoro-AcAP (prepared from 3-oxoproline) but failed to cycloetherify it, forming (1R,2R,8S)-7,7-difluoro-2hydroxy-AcAP as the sole product. The divergent LolO-catalyzed reactions of the difluorinated AcAP analogues provide insight into the LolO cycloetherification mechanism and indicate that the 7,7-difluorinated compound, in particular, may be a useful tool to accumulate and characterize the iron intermediate that initiates the cycloetherification reaction.