Purpose-The purpose of this paper is to provide library professionals with insights into students' fake news judgment and the importance of teaching media and information literacy, not as an option but as a core educational requirement. Design/methodology/approach-Qualtrics was used to collect the study data. Students completed a set of tasks designed in the form of a survey that entailed verifying whether news, stories, images and news sources were real, fake, dubious or trustworthy. Statistical tests were used to asses whether their responses depended on criteria, such as faculty and gender. Findings-No significant relationship exists between the students' responses and variables, such as gender, student category, fact-checking and source of information. The findings reveal that students' ability to identify the authoritativeness of information is dependent on the faculty in which they are enrolled. Originality/value-This paper reports the first known attempt in Lebanon to measure students' ability in distinguishing fake from real news. The results of this paper can be used by library professionals, particularly in Lebanon, to convey the importance of teaching and embedding media and information literacy into their curriculum.