One economy, but different growth regimes: why Germany’s rural east is still lagging

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to elucidate the quantitative and qualitative differences in employment development between German districts. Building on ideas from competitive development and resource-based theory, the paper particularly seeks to explain enduring East-West differences between rural regions by two different forms of competitive advantage: cost leadership and quality differentiation. Design/methodology/approach This study follows a two-step empirical approach: First, an extended shift-share regression is conducted to analyze employment development in Western and Eastern German districts between 2007 and 2016. Second, the competitive share effect and other individual terms of the shift-share model are further examined in additional regressions using regional economic characteristics as exogenous variables. Findings The findings suggest that the above-average employment growth of the rural districts in the West is owed to the successful exploitation of experience in manufacturing that has been gathered by firms in the past 100 years or so. While their strategy is largely based on advanced and specialized resources and an innovation-driven differentiation strategy, the relatively weak employment development of Eastern rural districts might be explained by a lack of comparable long-term experiences and the related need to focus on the exploitation of basic and general resources and, accordingly, on the efficiency-based strategy of cost leadership. Originality/value This study offers an in-depth empirical analysis of how the competitive share effect, i.e. region-specific resources beyond industry structure, contributes to regional employment development. The analysis reveals that quantitative differences in rural employment development are closely related to qualitatively different levels of input factors and different regimes of competitiveness.

Delays in Territorial Development – Case Study of the Hungarian Sand Ridge Region

“…Furthermore, the dilemma of place-based versus place-neutral TD concepts has emerged (Barca, 2012; Margarian & Hundt, 2023). Our standpoint aligns with Margarian (2013), who suggests that comprehensive development cannot be solely based on internal resources for specific regions (Farkas & Kovács, 2018).…”

Spatial Variation of Employment Growth in Poland in 2005-2021

“…Thus, it is appropriate to mention at this point similar cases known from the literature, fixed for example in the space of Canada -Heartland-Hinterland contrasts (Ray et al, 2012), the UK and Italy -North-South divide (Gardiner et al, 2013;Lagravinese, 2015) or Germany -West-East differences (Margarian and Hundt, 2023).…”