One foot on the dock and one foot on the boat: Differences among preservice science teachers' interpretations of field‐based science methods in culturally diverse contexts

Abstract

ABSTRACT:To support lasting change in science classrooms, efforts must be made to assist teachers in understanding the outcomes of their pedagogical choices. The process of reflection is not limited to experienced teachers' experiences, though we must recognize that preservice teachers do not draw upon the same vast repertoire and knowledge. The purpose of this study was to investigate preservice science teachers' beliefs about science teaching and learning through reflections on their own teaching with lower track science students. Using the major data sources of videotapes of teaching, stimulated recall interviews, and student journals we studied preservice teachers enrolled in a field based secondary science methods course working predominantly with rural Black children. Initially, preservice science teachers demonstrated similar practices, made similar inferences about teaching and learning, and relied upon similar domains of knowledge to gauge their teaching. By the end of the study, two discrete categories of preservice teachers emerged: (1) those who demonstrated an ability to reflect on and revise their practices and engage in the production of new teacher knowledge and (2) those who seemingly deflected efforts to shift their thinking and instead reproduced their own educational experience with a new student population.

First steps in teaching argumentation: A South African study

“…What seems clear is that student teachers who are most successful in their interactions, and who often obtained highest levels of argumentation from their learners, were those who stepped beyond the functional elements they were taught in the university course. This fits with Yerrick and Hoving's idea that student teachers, as novice practitioners, can be seen as those who 'reproduce' what has been set out to them at university and those who 'produce' more than this, going further when they practice teaching (Yerrick and Hoving, 2003). Thus Thea, Maria, Shane and Vuyani could be seen as 'producers' and Vusi, Alan, Stanley, Bulelwa and Carmen as 'reproducers'.…”

The Classroom Practice of a Prospective Secondary Biology Teacher and His Conceptions of the Nature of Science and of Teaching and Learning Science

“…Then Miguel was subsequently given an audio-recorded stimulated recall interview, in which he analyzed, together with the investigator, his own behavior in the classroom. The stimulated recall interview has been used in other work to study the beliefs of science teachers (Yerrick & Hoving, 2003).…”

Evolution of the conceptions of a secondary education biology teacher: Longitudinal analysis using cognitive maps

“…The stimulated recall interview has been used in other work to study the beliefs of science teachers (Yerrick & Hoving, 2003). Our aim in the present study was to reconstruct the trajectory of Consuelo's career with the help of the 1993 and 2002 maps.…”