Radiative and nonradiative electron spin-flip probabilities are analyzed in both plane wave and focused laser backgrounds. We provide a simple and physically transparent description of spin dynamics in plane waves, and demonstrate that there exists a kinematic regime in which the usual leading-order perturbative hierarchy of quantum electrodynamics is reversed, and nonradiative loop effects dominate over radiative tree-level spin flips. We show that while this loop dominance becomes suppressed in focused laser pulses due to a high sensitivity to field geometry, there is nevertheless a regime in which, in principle, loop effects on spin transitions can be discerned.