“…In order to improve the efficiency of Biginelli reaction, a variety of catalysts have been reported which of them H 4 PMo 11 VO 40 [9], Dowex-50W [10], H 3 PW 12 O 40 /SiO 2 [11], MgBr 2 [12], polymer-supported 4-aminoformoyldiphenylammonium triflate [13], NaHSO 4 /SiO 2 [14], FeCl 3 [15], ZrCl 4 [16], Cu(OTf) 2 [17], Bi(OTf) 3 [18], yutterbium triflate [19], 12-molbdophosphoric acid [20], natural HEU type zeolite [21], Sr(OTf) 2 [22], covalently anchored sulfonic acid onto silica [23] [34] are examples.…”