One Size Does Not Fit All in Psychotherapy: Understanding Depression Among Patients of Turkish Origin in Europe

Abstract

Over the last decades, Europe has become an immigration country hosting an estimated 56 million international immigrants. Yet, a large amount of literature suggests that migration is associated with a higher risk of common mental disorders, such as depression and anxiety. As representatives of one of the largest immigrant groups in Europe, various studies have shown that Turkish immigrants exhibit a higher prevalence of depression and anxiety disorders than do the background population. Nevertheless, it is also well demonstrated that this particular patient group is more likely to terminate treatment prematurely and displays lower rates of treatment compliance than their native counterparts. This reluctance for service utilization might be partially because of the fact that people from non-Western ethno-cultural backgrounds (e.g., Turkey) often have a different notion and comprehension of mental health and illness as compared with those of the people from Western societies. Such mismatch often results in discrepancies between the needs and expectations of immigrant patients and clinicians, which attenuate the communication and effectiveness of treatment and lead to unexplained high dropout rates. To provide continued provision of culture-sensitive, high quality, evidence-based mental health care, the advancement of researches exploring such sociocultural differences between the patients' and the clinicians' notions of mental health must occur. In response to these problems, the current review aims to explore the interplay between culture and mental processes that associate with the etiology, maintenance, and management of depression among Turkish immigrant patients. This is to inform clinicians regarding culture-specific correlates of depression among Turkish patients to enable them to present interventions that fit the needs and expectations of this particular patient group.

A Cross-Sectional Study on the Prevalence of Depressive Symptoms and Its Associated Sociodemographic Factors in Peru during the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…Cultural and personal differences on collectivism or individualism might be related to psychological responses to the pandemic [ 67 ]. How spending time with friends and family is valued in some cultures could result in an increase or decrease in psychological well-being and depressive symptoms [ 68 , 69 ]. As evidence, several studies found mixed results regarding the relationship between member cohabiting during the pandemic and mental health conditions [ 70 , 71 , 72 ], since other cultural factors or even quality of the relationships might be intervening [ 67 , 73 ].…”

Predictors for successful psychotherapy: Does migration status matter?

“…Concerning Polish and Italian immigrants, studies draw a similar picture in terms of poorer mental health compared to non-migrants [ 87 – 89 ]. In societies which are structured in a more collectivistic manner than a lot of Western societies, mental illness is often perceived as a psychosocial issue or an emotional reaction to disruption in social relationships [ 90 ]. Researchers and psychotherapists should therefore give more attention to the social surroundings and societal and cultural dynamics the individual patient comes from.…”

The Interactive Effect of Goal Attainment and Goal Importance on Acculturation and Well-Being

“…Realistic and tangible goals may be more attainable and as such affect acculturation and well-being of migrants. There is a higher need for psychological counseling among migrants as compared to non-migrants (Balkir Neftçi and Barnow, 2016). Clinicians may want to focus on helping migrants find motivating goals for which attainment is feasible and rewarding.…”