One Size Does Not Fit All: AptitudexTreatment Interaction (ATI) as a Conceptual Framework for Complementary and Alternative Medicine Outcome Research. Part 1—What Is ATI Research?

Abstract

When multiple treatment choices are available, the question is not just "which treatment is the best?" but more importantly "best or better for whom, when, and why?" Aptitude (or attribute) by treatment interaction (ATI) is a research paradigm that attempts to examine exactly that--how outcome depends on the match or mismatch between patients' specific characteristics and the treatment they receive. The purpose of this two-part paper is to introduce ATI methods as a conceptual framework into complementary and alternative medicine/integrative medicine (CAM/IM) outcome research. Part 1 presents key concepts in ATI research. Part 2 will present ATI research designs and discusses their applications to the examination of the relationships between individuals and therapies, and the illumination of the mechanisms that make therapies differentially effective. Based on this examination, we conclude that ATI research offers invaluable insights into the multifaceted package of care typically delivered in contemporary medicine and therefore should be included in the portfolio of all CAM/IM outcome research.

Demand-side vs. supply-side technology policies: Hidden treatment and new empirical evidence on the policy mix

“…This kind of confounding factor can be seen as a hidden treatment (Huston, 1997). The problem is very well known in clinical research, when typically various compounds are administered to patients as a cure for the same disease (Thall et al, 2000), and in the alternative medicine/integrative medicine framework, which studies the interaction of alternative and integrative medicine with the administration of standard compounds (Caspi and Bell, 2004).…”

The Process of Whole Person Healing: “Unstuckness” and Beyond

“…16 With the identification of outcomes, however, comes the opportunity to begin identifying the states, characteristics, processes, and modifying factors leading up to transformation. Such research could have substantial clinical relevance, in assisting clinicians of all types in identifying those individuals for whom specific CAM treatments may be most beneficial, [17][18][19] and in enhancing ongoing treatment programs to achieve optimal outcomes for more people.…”

Patients' Experiences and Perceptions of a Consultative Model Integrative Medicine Clinic: A Qualitative Study

“…It is critical to begin to link the model of practice with particular patient populations and needs so that we can begin to develop and test hypotheses about which model might be most beneficial and yield positive patient outcomes in specific patient situations. 3,28,29 Therefore, the purpose of this study was to use qualitative methods to examine the experiences and responses of cancer patients to care and treatment within a consultative IM practice model and to compare these experiences to those of other chronically ill patients.…”