We present a systematic study of the moduli space of asymptotically flat, supersymmetric and biaxisymmetric black hole solutions to five-dimensional minimal supergravity. Previously, it has been shown that such solutions must be multi-centred solutions with a Gibbons-Hawking base. In this paper we perform a full analysis of three-centred solutions with a single black hole, for which there are seven regular black hole solutions. We find that four of these can have the same conserved charges as the BMPV black hole. These consist of a black lens with L(3, 1) horizon topology and three distinct families of spherical black holes with nontrivial topology outside the horizon. The former provides the first example of a nonspherical black hole with the same conserved charges as the BMPV black hole. Moreover, of these four solutions, three can have a greater entropy than the BMPV black hole near the BMPV upper spin bound. One of these is a previously known spherical black hole with nontrivial topology and the other two are new examples of a spherical black hole with nontrivial topology and an L(3, 1) black lens.Recently, a complete classification of asymptotically flat, supersymmetric and biaxisymmetric black hole (and soliton) solutions to five-dimensional minimal supergravity has been derived [17]. This reveals a vast moduli space of spherical black holes, black rings and black lenses in spacetimes with noncontractible 2-cycles. This includes all the above examples, but also reveals infinitely many more black hole solutions for each horizon topology. Given this, one expects the above example of supersymmetric black hole non-uniqueness to be merely the tip of the iceberg. Indeed, several natural questions present themselves: Are there other black hole solutions with the same charges as the BMPV black hole? Do any of these have nonspherical horizon topology? Do any of these have greater entropy than the BMPV black hole?The purpose of this paper is to use the recent classification [17] to perform a systematic study of the moduli space of supersymmetric black holes of five-dimensional minimal supergravity. In particular, we wish to study in detail the moduli space of solutions with the same conserved charges as the BMPV black hole. Even given the explicit classification this is technically challenging and at present out of reach. This is essentially due to the fact the general solution depends on many parameters that are subject to polynomial equations and several inequalities, arising from smoothness and causality, which are difficult to disentangle. The classification shows that the solutions must have a Gibbons-Hawking base with 1 This has also been observed for multi-black rings and black holes [10,11] and asymptotically AdS black holes [12].