There is a long-standing debate in educational settings on the influence of positive and negative consequences on learning. Although positive rewards seem desirable from an ethical perspective, 1-trial learning has been best demonstrated in the animal literature with tasks using highly salient negative consequences, such as shock or illness, and so far only in tasks requiring the acquisition of a singular stimulus-response association. Here we show that pigeons and baboons can concurrently learn, in a cognitively challenging memorization task, hundreds of pictureresponse associations after a single exposure and that this rapid learning is better promoted by a positive outcome after the first picture presentation. Further, the early positive outcomes had beneficial effects on the memory of learned acquisitions that was detectable up to 6 -8 months after initial training. Beyond their significance for educational policies, these findings suggest that the psychological and brain mechanisms controlling rapid, often 1-trial, learning have a long evolutionary history. They may represent the phylogenetic precursor for the disproportionate impact of first impressions in humans and the phenomenon of fast word learning in children.monkey ͉ positive reinforcement ͉ fast mapping ͉ picture processing ͉ bird A long standing debate in educational settings concerns the relative efficacy of positive and negative outcomes in promoting learning and in dealing with the modification of problem behaviors (1, 2) Despite the desirability of using positive rewards, the best animal evidence of rapid learning (i.e., 1-trial learning) come from experiments involving highly salient negative consequences, such as shock or illness (3-7). However, positive rewards may also have important effects on the speed of learning, because rewards have the advantage of directly communicating and confirming what an animal should do as opposed to what behavior should not be performed. Extensive brain structures are known to be associated with positive rewards (8-10).To further explore the role of positive reinforcement in producing rapid learning in a cognitively demanding situation, we examined learning in a picture memorization task testing 2 highly visual, but distantly related species, pigeons and baboons (11, 12). Here we show that these 2 species can learn very large numbers of concurrent picture-response associations after only a single presentation and that this 1-trial learning and its long-term retention over months was promoted by an early positive reinforcement at the first presentation of each image.
ResultsTwo pigeons (BF and Linus) and 2 baboons (B03 and B09) had to continually learn and recall right-or left-choice responses to increasing number of pictures presented in a 2-alternative choice task. Correct answers were rewarded by positive reinforcements (food), whereas incorrect answers were mildly punished by a short timeout before the next trial. Because the original mapping of the pictures to the responses was arbitrary, the task require...