Online recruitment of a non-help-seeking sample for an internet intervention: Lessons learned in an alcohol-exposed pregnancy risk reduction study

Abstract

BackgroundRecruiting a hidden population, such as the population of women at risk for alcohol-exposed pregnancy (AEP) who binge drink and are at risk of an unintended pregnancy, is challenging as this population is not typically seeking help or part of an identifiable group. We sought to identify affordable and efficient methods of recruitment for hidden populations.MethodsSeveral popular online social media and advertising sites were identified. Cities with high rates of binge drinking among women were targeted. We placed advertisements and study notices using Facebook, Twitter, Craigslist, University postings, and ClinicalTrials.gov.ResultsFor this study, 75 women at risk for AEP were recruited from across the U.S. within 7 months. Online advertising for study participants on Craigslist resulted in enrollment of the majority 51 (68%) of the study participants. While Craigslist advertising could be tailored to specific locations with high rates of binge drinking among women, there were challenges to using Craigslist. These included automated deletion due to repeated postings and mention of sexual behavior or drinking, requiring increased efforts and resources by the study team. Several strategies were developed to optimize advertising on Craigslist. Approximately 100 h of staff time valued at $2500 was needed over the 7-month recruitment period.DiscussionDespite challenges, the target sample of women at risk for AEP was recruited in the 7 month recruitment period using online advertising methods. We recommend that researchers consider online classified advertisements when recruiting from non-help seeking populations. By taking advantage of national data to target specific risk factors, and by tailoring advertising efforts, it is possible to efficiently and affordably recruit a non-treatment seeking sample.

The Effect of Dissemination Pathways on Uptake and Relative Costs for a Transdiagnostic, Self-guided Internet Intervention for Reducing Depression, Anxiety, and Suicidal Ideation: Comparative Implementation Study

“…This may reflect the reluctance of people to engage with an intervention that is seen as distinct from the care they receive from the provider. It is possible that privacy concerns may influence decisions to engage more in public settings than when using the internet in private settings [ 58 ]. Furthermore, the web-based modality of the intervention may be more conducive to direct web-based dissemination than via the use of posters.…”

Public health policies and alcohol-related liver disease

“…102,103 Finally, the internet and social medial have been used to engage young people or target populations, like pregnant women, who otherwise would not seek specialised care for their alcohol problems. 104 Further studies should evaluate the efficacy of both regulatory and educational campaigns on social media.…”

Reactions to a Hypothetical Menthol Cigarette Ban among Sexual- and Gender-Minoritized Communities: A Concept Mapping Study

“…Craigslist has previously been identified as an online space used by racially diverse SGM communities [26,27], SGM individuals living in rural areas [28], and minoritized groups more generally [29]. As diverse SGM samples are regarded as "hidden" and remain hard to access [26], SGM individuals frequently use online platforms to access community [30], and Craigslist has been reported to be an effective recruitment tool [28,31] that produces quality data [32], this platform was chosen for recruitment. By the end of recruitment, advertisements were posted in 59 locations within 47 states and Washington, D.C.…”