“…This short commemoration piece wishes to highlight positive dimensions in scientific publishing. While I have directed much of my recent attention to the oppositeto the criticism of the current development in market-driven academic publishing (see Kallio, 2017;Kallio & Hyvärinen, 2017;Kallio & Metzger, 2018;Kallio & Riding, 2019;Riding et al, 2020) here I share my experiences from working with Ronan Paddison for over 10 years, while he was the editor-in-chief of Space and Polity, to argue for what should be preserved and further developed in academic journals, be they commercial or nonprofit. During my academic career I have learned that the quality of editorial work does not depend on such matters, any more than it has to do with the indexing or impact factor of the journal, rather editorial attitude and understanding are decisive.…”