I relate the historic successes, and present difficulties, ofthe renormalized quasiparticle theory ofmetals ("AGD" or Fermi liquid theory). I then describe the bestunderstood example of a non-Fermi liquid, the normal metallic state of the cuprate superconductors.For some 40 years, almost all electronic phenomena in metals have been interpreted in terms of a general theoretical framework, which one could variously call renormalized free particle theory, Fermi liquid theory, or "AGD" after the best-known book on the subject (1).I came to the conclusion a few years ago that this theory is, in many of the most interesting cases, basically a failure. For the first 20 years of its history, until the mid-1970s, it served us very well; but then as we began to focus on the most interesting (or the most anomalous) cases, more and more of the copious literature of our subject came to be engaged in fitting the proverbial square peg into a round hole. It is not that there are no instances that fit the framework but that, contrary to the claims for universality which have been made for it, it seems that for systems with strong interactions, it often is completely misguiding.To make my point I must first describe the nature of this conventional theory. It arose in the 1950s, just after the successes of the Schwinger-Feynman-Dyson theory in quantum electrodynamics, and it borrows the techniques that were so successful in that theory. In quantum electrodynamics, the scheme was to map the properties of the real physical vacuum and the real physical particle excitations onto the corresponding entities of a supposed bare vacuum with bare particles by the process of renormalization. One defines a propagator or Green's function, G(r -r', t -t'), which is the amplitude for finding a particle at point r and time t if it was inserted at point r' and time t' into the real vacuum. The particle can encounter various interactions with vacuum fluctuations on the way, which are sorted out into a series with Feynman diagrams. If this series is well-behaved, its sum can be written in terms of a self-energy, which merely renormalizes the unperturbed propagator without changing its essential character.In the condensed matter physics of metals there is no vacuum, but there is a Fermi sea if the electrons are noninteracting. This is treated formally as a vacuum in which both hole and particle excitations can propagate, in parallel to the treatment in quantum electrodynamics of the Dirac sea of negative-energy electrons as a vacuum for positrons. There is a surface in p space of zero energy, the Fermi surface. The unperturbed Green's function [Fourier transformed into momentum (p) and energy (t) space] is 1 G(o,p) = -(e -,