Central corneal thickness is a quantitative trait with important associations to human health. In a phenotype-driven approach studying corneal thickness of congenic derivatives of C57BLKS/J and SJL/J mice, the critical region for a quantitative trait locus influencing corneal thickness, Cctq1a, was delimited to a 10-gene interval. Exome sequencing, RNAseq, and studying independent mutations eliminated multiple candidate genes and confirmed one. Though the causative gene, Tyr, has no obvious direct function in the transparent cornea, studies with multiple alleles on matched genetic backgrounds, both in isolation and genetic complementation crosses, confirmed allelism of Tyr-Cctq1a; albino mice lacking Tyr function had thin corneas. Albino mice also had increased axial length. Because albinism exposes eyes to increased light, the effect of dark-rearing was tested and found to rescue central corneal thickness. In sum, the results point to an epiphenomenon; developmental light exposure interacts with genotype as an important determinate of adult corneal thickness.