Optimal Thrust Allocation for Semisubmersible Oil Rig Platforms Using Improved Harmony Search Algorithm

Abstract

Deep-water offshore drilling vessels, such as a semisubmersible drilling rig, use the dynamic positioning (DP) system and the thruster-assisted position-mooring system for maintaining a stationary position. In the DP system, the thrust allocator is used to distribute the desired generalized forces computed by the motion controller among the thrusters. However, to ensure safe operation of the vessel despite the thruster failure, the vessel is equipped with redundant thruster configuration and, therefore, is overactuated. For overactuated vessels, the choice of a particular solution for thrust allocation is found using some kind of optimization process. In this paper, the thrust allocator tries to minimize the power consumption and takes forbidden/spoil zones into account. The formulated thrust allocation problem becomes nonconvex due to thrust direction constraints on azimuth thrusters. The conventional methods get trapped in local minima and fail to find the optimum solution for the formulated nonconvex thrust allocation problem. In this paper, an improved harmony search (IHS) algorithm for solving the nonconvex thrust allocation problem is proposed. IHS is a variant of the harmony search (HS) algorithm. The HS algorithm is a music-based meta-heuristic optimization method, which is analogous with the music improvisation process where a musician continues to polish the pitches to obtain better harmony. Obtained numerical results show that the IHS algorithm has better convergence property when compared to the HS algorithm and the genetic algorithm (GA). Moreover, the power consumption for thrust allocation using the IHS algorithm is lower when compared with HS, GA, and Mincon (sequential quadratic programming) algorithms. The percentage savings in total power consumption for thruster allocation as compared to the Mincon algorithm for GA, HS, and IHS methods are 44.96%, 48.39%, and 51.58%, respectively.Index Terms-Dynamic positioning (DP), genetic algorithm (GA), harmony search (HS), optimization, thrust allocation problem.

Feasibility Study of Electromechanical Cylinder Drivetrain for Offshore Mechatronic Systems

“…More specifically, the shipping sector has developed an interest in using variable speed AC drives for ship propulsion applications (Sakuraba et al, 1992). Similarly, all-electric vessels and dynamic positioning (DP) systems are the concepts that contribute to an increased popularity of electric motors due to the lowered energy consumption, smooth and silent operation, as well as improved controllability properties that they offer compared to traditional hydraulic systems (Yadav et al, 2014). Also, the percentage share of electric actuation systems in oil and gas production units constantly increases, according to Rahimi et al (2011) and Gallant and Andrews (2006).…”

Station-keeping control of an unmanned surface vehicle exposed to current and wind disturbances

“…3). This is formulated as an optimization problem, and techniques such as linear programming [37], [60], quadratic programming [61], and evolutionary algorithms [62] can be used to find an optimal, or near optimal, solution. Actuator dynamics create constraints on this system, leading to a constrained nonlinear optimization problem, which is nontrivial to solve.…”

Hydraulic vs. Electric: A Review of Actuation Systems in Offshore Drilling Equipment

“…Figure 2: Comparison of complexity levels of popular actuation systems (Rivenbark et al, 2007) Smooth control and silent operation that variable speed AC drives provide is recognized in shipping and marine sector as well (Sakuraba et al, 1992). Recently, all-electric vessels have become increasingly popular with dynamic positioning (DP) systems receiving special attention -see for instance (Yadav et al, 2014) and the references therein. A solution with a variable pitch propeller and a fixed rotational speed has been the most popular so far.…”