This paper presents a particular tunneling method, the new Austrian tunneling method (NATM), which plays an important role in reducing subsidence of the surface and damage to structures in urban areas. It has a wide range of applications in shallow tunneling projects all over the world. In this study, numerical modeling of the third-line Metro tunnel in Tehran, which is designed and stabilized by the NATM, is under discussion. The foregoing tunnel is excavated manually with a one-meter advancing step. In this project, the constructors use a lattice girder and spray concrete with 31 cm thickness as the initial lining. A suitable numerical software for this modeling is PLAXIS 3D Tunnel, which allows high-resolution finite element modeling (FEM) of the studied object. The performance of this method is investigated and compared with that of other NATMs. The numerical modeling yielded a value of 30.01 mm for earth subsidence in the most damaged area of the settlement, which was confirmed with a dramatically low difference by earth surface monitoring. Moreover, this tunnel was drilled and excavated using various methods, among which the least settlement was obtained by the proposed method. The results are promising, and they indicate that tunneling with this method should continue to be used to expand the subway line in the city.