Large corporations have recently demonstrated an increasing propensity to enhance the sustainability and reliability of their supply chains in order to comply with environmental regulations and improve customer satisfaction through on-time demand fulfillment. There are two phases to this study: mathematical modeling and model solution using precise techniques. In the first step, a mixed-integer linear programming model is developed. This model is an improvement of an existing supply chain model. Further, our suggested strategy is verified by using numerical data based on three criteria and four suppliers. The goals of the proposed model are to maximize supply chain reliability, economic profit, and social responsibilities by taking suppliers’ priorities into account. Modeled as a mixed-integer linear programming problem, the constraints on the problem include budget, emission, demand, allocation, facility, and shipping capacity. Power symmetry and information symmetry are incorporated in order to perform symmetric analysis. The weighted sum method (WSM) and the technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) are the two methods used in the second step of solving the model to identify the best supplier. In order to evaluate how well the proposed methodology was applied, a practical case was considered and implemented.