The combination of hot-wire insertion technology and gas metal arc welding (GMAW) is proposed to increase deposition rate and reduce power consumption. This study systematically investigated the effect of hot-wire fraction on weld metal properties. The results show that the compensatory deposition rate from hot-wire insertion provides a similar effective height compared with the rate from conventional GMAW, with a lower weld height/width ratio, lower power consumption, and improved mechanical properties. However, an excessive hot-wire fraction can lead to lack of fusion, and this value should be limited to no more than 44% of the total deposition rate. The relative GMAW and hotwire fractions were optimized to maximize total deposition volume while avoiding lack of fusion and providing sufficient penetration. With the optimized condition, hot-wire GMAW could be efficiently used to obtain similar deposition rates with lower power consumption and without sacrificing toughness properties. This proposed process offers a sustainable alternative development to conventional GMAW.