Optimizing associated liver partition and portal vein ligation for staged hepatectomy outcomes: Surgical experience or appropriate patient selection?

Abstract

Background: Early reports of associated liver partition and portal vein ligation for staged hepatectomy (ALPPS) outcomes have been suboptimal. The literature has confirmed that learning curves influence surgical outcomes. We have 54 months of continuous experience performing ALPPS with strict selection criteria. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of the learning curve on ALPPS outcomes. Methods:We retrospectively compared patients who underwent ALPPS between April 2012 and March 2016. Patients were grouped into 2 24-month (early and late) periods. All candidates had a high tumour load requiring staged hepatectomy after chemotherapy response, a predicted future liver remnant (FLR) less than 30% and good performance status. Results:Thirty-three patients underwent ALPPS during the study period: 16 in the early group (median age 65 yr, mean body mass index [BMI] 27) and 17 in the late group (median age 60 yr, mean BMI 25). Bilobar disease was comparable in both groups (94% v. 88%, p > 0.99). Duration of surgery was not statistically different. Intraoperative blood loss and need for transfusion were significantly lower in the late group (200 ± 109 mL v. 100 ± 43 mL, p < 0.05). The late group had a higher proportion of monosegment ALPPS (4:1). There were no deaths within 90 days in either cohort. Rates of postoperative complications were not statistically significant between groups. The R0 resection rate was similar. The entire 1-year disease-free and overall survival were 52% and 84%, respectively. Conclusion:Excellent results can be obtained in innovative complex surgery with careful patient selection and good technical skills. Additionally, the learning curve brought confidence to perform more complex procedures while maintaining good outcomes.Contexte : Les premiers résultats sur l'association de la partition hépatique et de la ligature portale pour l'hépatectomie en 2 temps (ALPPS) sont sous-optimaux. La littérature a confirmé que les courbes d'apprentissage influencent les résultats des interventions chirurgicales. Notre étude reposait sur 54 mois consécutifs d'utilisation de la technique ALPPS selon des critères de sélection rigoureux. Elle visait à évaluer l'effet de la courbe d'apprentissage sur les résultats liés à l'ALPPS.Méthodes : Nous avons procédé à une comparaison rétrospective des patients traités par l'ALPPS entre avril 2012 et mars 2016. Nous avons divisé les patients en 2 groupes de 24 mois (précoce et tardif). Tous les candidats avaient une charge tumorale élevée nécessitant une hépatectomie en 2 temps après une réponse à la chimiothérapie, un volume estimé de futur foie résiduel (FFR) inférieur à 30 % et un indice fonctionnel favorable. Résultats :Trente-trois patients ont été traités par l'ALPPS pendant la période de l'étude : 16 dans le groupe précoce (âge médian 65 ans, indice de masse corporelle [IMC] moyen 27) et 17 dans le groupe tardif (âge médian 60 ans, IMC moyen 25). Le taux de maladie bilobaire était comparable entre les 2 groupes (94 % c. 88 %, p > 0,99). La durée de la chirurgie...

Efficacy of the association liver partition and portal vein ligation for staged hepatectomy for the treatment of solitary huge hepatocellular carcinoma: a retrospective single-center study

“…ALPPS is labeled as a high-risk operation due to its initially reported high morbidity and mortality [31]. However, a learning curve in ALPPS is observed, and things have gone into gradually reverse as improvement of patient selection, interstage management, and ALPPS technique [32,33]. A study of the International ALPPS Registry shows that the 90-day mortality decreases from 17 to 4% in 2015 among 437 patients from 16 centers [13].…”