“…For example, studies that document the positive relationship between CE and postsecondary success (e.g., Allen & Dadgar, 2012;An, 2013a;Karp et al;Speroni, 2011;Struhl & Vargas, 2012;Swanson, 2008;Taylor, 2015) that use state or national datasets often fail to examine differences in outcomes based on the nature of the CE experience or environment (e.g., instructor type or location). Only a small number of studies have examined differences in CE outcomes by course location and instructor type, and these studies lead to mixed results (e.g., D'Amico et al, 2013;Dixon & Slate, 2014;Lochmiller et al, 2016;Phelps & Chan, 2016). Further, two of these studies use only descriptive statistics and they do not account for factors other than course location and instructor type that might influence student outcomes.…”