This study was aimed at explaining the effect of thermal history on strain-induced recrystallization of poly-(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF) blended with 20−60 wt % of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA). The nonisothermally meltcrystallized blends cooled at either 20 or 1 K/min revealed significantly different tensile properties. For example, the PVDF:PMMA 80:20 blend crystallized at 1 K/min revealed a Young's modulus and ultimate strength, respectively, over 12-fold and 2-fold higher than the blend crystallized at 20 K/min. Tensile properties of the blends were found to be a consequence of their thermal histories. The X-ray diffraction and FTIR analysis indicated that the tensile properties of the blends were not simply related to the initial PVDF crystallinity. Our results indirectly suggested that mechanical properties were affected by the nature of the amorphous phase along with recrystallization of PVDF. The strain-induced recrystallization caused formation of the polar PVDF polymorphs (β and γ). We have identified two distinct recrystallization mechanisms involving: (i) α-crystals unfolding or (ii) α-crystal fragmentation. In the blends cooled at 20 K/min, the increasing strain caused a decrease in the α-phase fraction, attributable to the unfolding of the α-crystals. Formation of the polar polymorphs was concomitant with the decline in the α-phase. Since the reduction in the α-phase fraction was compensated by the mass of the newly formed polar polymorphs, the total PVDF crystallinity for the α-crystals unfolding mechanism was practically constant over the strain. The deformation of the stiffer and tougher, slowly cooled blends caused the breaking and fragmentation of the α-crystals. The fragmentation was volume-conserving, and no significant changes in the α-phase fraction were observed. The polar crystals were formed out of the amorphous phase, contributing, therefore, to the increased total crystallinity of PVDF. Our results endorsed the recent hypotheses about the existence of the polar, trans-configuration-dominated, amorphous PVDF. The latter has important implications for understanding the crystallinity, its determination, and electroactivity of vinylidene fluoride-based polymers.