Poly‐p‐xylylenes were prepared by electrolytic reduction of α,α′‐dihalo‐p‐xylenes at controlled cathode potentials (c.p.). Polymers and halides are formed at the cathode; at the anode the halide is oxidized to halogen. Poly‐p‐xylylene was prepared from α,α′‐dichloro‐p‐xylene (c.p. −1.2 v.) and α,α′‐dibromo‐p‐xylene (c.p. −1.2 v.); poly‐p‐2‐chloroxylylene from α,α′,2‐trichloro‐p‐xylene (c.p. −1.4 v.) and α,α′‐dibromo‐2‐chloro‐p‐xylene (c.p. −1.2 v.); poly‐α,α,α′,α′‐tetrachloro‐p‐xylylene from α,α,α,α′,α′,α′‐hexachloro‐p‐xylene (c.p. −0.7 v.), and poly‐α,α,α′,α′‐tetrafluoro‐p‐xylylene from α,α′‐dibromo‐α,α,α′,α′‐tetrafluoro‐p‐xylene (c.p. −1.1 v.). The cathode potentials were measured and controlled with respect to a saturated calomel electrode. Current efficiencies up to 96% were observed. α,α,α′,α′‐Tetrachloro‐p‐xylylene was identified as an intermediate in the reduction of α,α,α,α′,α′,α′‐hexachloro‐p‐xylene. A general mechanism for these reactions is suggested and discussed. It involves elimination of halide by a two‐electron charge transfer with formation of a xylyl anion, followed by an elimination of halide in α′‐position yielding xylylenes which then polymerize.