Organising Concepts of ‘Women’s Empowerment’ for Measurement: A Typology

Abstract

Improving the conceptualisation and measurement of women's empowerment has been repeatedly identified as a research priority for global development policy. We apply arguments from feminist and political philosophy to develop a unified typology of empowerment concepts to guide measurement and evaluation. In this typology, empowerment (1) may be a property of individuals or collectives (2) may involve removing internal psychological barriers or external interpersonal barriers (3) may be defined on each agent’s own terms or by external agents in advance (4) may require agents to acquire a degree of independence or require others to ‘empower’ them through social support (5) may either concern the number of present options or the motivations behind past choices. We argue a careful examination of arguments for and against each notion of empowerment reveal fundamental fact-, theory- and value-based incompatibilities between contrasting notions. Thus, empowerment is an essentially contested concept that cannot be captured by simply averaging a large number of contrasting measures. We argue that researchers and practitioners measuring this concept may benefit from making explicit their theory-, fact- and value-based assumptions about women’s empowerment before settling on a single primary measure for their particularly context. Alternative indicators can subsequently be used as sensitivity measures that not only measure sensitivity to assumptions about women’s social reality, but also to investigators’ own values.

'There is no point giving cash to women who don't spend it the way they are told to spend it' – Exploring women's agency over cash in a combined participatory women's groups and cash transfer programme to improve low birthweight in rural Nepal

“…Indeed, republicans may argue behavioural constraints designed by the NGO and the community to promote pregnant women's health and nutrition carry greater legitimacy than arbitrary confiscation of cash transfers by other household members. More broadly, collectively agreed constraints on individual behaviour are often necessary to reach collective goals and produce public goods (Gram et al, 2018b, Gram et al, 2018c). Our findings indicate a need for considering conceptions of agency, which distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate interference (Gram et al, 2017).…”

Women’s economic empowerment and health related decision-making in rural Sierra Leone

“…Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 5 identifies achieving gender equality and empowering all women and girls as one of the key steps towards achieving inclusive and sustainable development by 2030. However, the meaning and measurement of the concept of empowerment has been contested (Gram, Morrison, and Skordis-Worrall 2018). Most social science research has based its conceptualisation of empowerment on the notion of 'agency', defined by Sen as the 'ability to use those capabilities and opportunities to expand the choices they have' (Sen 1999, 10), and on women's ability to participate in decision-making over certain vital matters (e.g.…”

Women’s income and risk of intimate partner violence: secondary findings from the MAISHA cluster randomised trial in North-Western Tanzania

“…It is now widely accepted that associations between a woman's economic circumstances and IPV risk differ according to the economic indicator used [37], type of violence [38], and setting, though empirical evidence to explain this variation and unpack mechanisms of association is limited [7]. The increase in risk that has been observed in some settings has been attributed to a 'malebacklash'as women gain more economic autonomy, men who feel that their authority is being challenged may increase their use of violence as a means of reasserting their control [31,39,40].…”