Organization of nursing care in three Nordic countries: relationships between nurses’ workload, level of involvement in direct patient care, job satisfaction, and intention to leave

Abstract

BackgroundHealth care systems in Finland, Norway and Sweden share many similarities, e.g. full-coverage and tax-financed, with predominately public sector hospitals. Despite similarities, there are differences in the working situations for RNs within these Nordic countries. The aim of this study was to analyze associations between RNs’ patient workload and level of involvement in direct patient care, their job satisfaction and intention to leave in these countries.MethodsA workforce survey was conducted through RN4CAST, an EU 7th framework project. The survey included 118 items derived from validated instruments or tested in prior research. Responses from 1133 RNs at 32 Finnish hospitals, 3752 RNs at 35 Norwegian hospitals, and 11 015 RNs at 71 Swedish hospitals comprise the database, which was analyzed using logistic and odds ratio regressions analyses.ResultsWe found statistically significant differences in RNs’ level of involvement in direct patient care (p < 0.001, Sweden compared to Norway and Finland), in patient workload and in number of patients needing ADL assistance and surveillance. A U-formed relationship was found between level of involvement in direct patient care and intention to leave in Sweden, and more satisfaction among RNs in roles with more direct patient care (OR = 1.16, 1.02 ≤ CI95% ≤ 1.32). Nearly half the Finnish sample report intention to leave, with significantly lower levels in Norway and Sweden (p < 0.001). Patient workload is associated with job satisfaction and intention to leave to some degree in all countries, i.e. greater patient workload, less job satisfaction and greater intention to leave.ConclusionsThis study suggests that more attention paid to patient mix, workload and role of RNs in patient care might potentially diminish intention to leave and increase job satisfaction in these Nordic countries.

Measuring professional satisfaction and nursing workload among nursing staff at a Greek Coronary Care Unit

“…More specifically, negative correlations were detected not only with the overall IWS score, but also with Status, Interaction, Tasks and Autonomy sub-scores. Although literature reports on workload and nurse job satisfaction are limited, our results are in accordance with the study that demonstrated a correlation between high workload and poor job satisfaction, followed by an intention to quit, among registered nurses in Nordic hospitals (28) . It appears that the current worldwide nursing shortage contributes to heavier workload, which leads to a more stressful job environment with more tasks to accomplish (under time pressure) and conflicts among healthcare professionals.…”

Job satisfaction among Swedish mental health nursing personnel: Revisiting the two‐factor theory

“…Currently, Sweden has no formalized system on a national or county level for clinical career ladders among nurses, neither for wages nor for further education, although certain employers might have their own standards (Lindqvist et al . ). The present study provided a deeper understanding of how Herzberg's theory can explain what motivates registered and assistant nurses to work in mental health care.…”

“…This has been suggested in several studies, and Lindqvist et al . () found that significantly more registered nurses from Norway reported that they would recommend their hospital to a colleague as a good place to work compared to Swedish nurses.…”

Pleasure-suffering indicators of nursing work in a hemodialysis nursing service

“…A study of nursing staff in Finland, Norway and Sweden found that most participants were satisfied with their profession, but workers with higher workload had lower professional fulfillment and the intention to leave their job (26) .…”