Organizational characteristics of nursing practice environments related to registered nurses’ professional autonomy and job satisfaction in two Finnish Magnet-aspiring hospitals: structural equation modeling study

Abstract

Background Nurses are leaving their profession because of poor personal job satisfaction, heavy workload, and unfavorable work environments with low professional autonomy. Professional autonomy involves the possibility to influence one’s work and have a sense of control – the ability to contribute to a workplace culture and influence how decisions are made. This study explores registered nurses’ perceptions of the nursing practice environment, using the Nursing Work Index-Revised (NWI-R), and its relationships with professional autonomy and job satisfaction. Methods A cross-sectional study along with instrument re-validation was conducted using a web-based survey for nurses in two Magnet-aspiring hospitals in Finland in September 2021 (n = 586). Structural equation modeling was used to find out the relationships of the NWI-R components with professional autonomy and job satisfaction. Results Principal component analysis and confirmatory factor analysis supported seven components with 34 items. Collegial nurse–doctor relationships, organization’s quality standards, and nursing involvement and expertise sharing (means of 3.23, 2.96, and 2.66, respectively) demonstrated a favorable nursing practice environment; professional nursing standards, nurse management and leadership, staffing and resource adequacy, and professional advancement (means of 2.38, 2.18, 2.15, and 2.13, respectively) demonstrated an unfavorable nursing practice environment. The presented model (RMSEA 0.068, CFI 0.987, TLI 0.946) indicated that nursing involvement and expertise sharing, organization’s quality standards, nurse management and leadership, and collegial nurse–doctor relationships were related to professional autonomy. Nurse management and leadership, staffing and resource adequacy, and organization’s quality standards were related to job satisfaction. Moreover, professional autonomy was related to job satisfaction. Conclusion Nurses’ professional autonomy is important due to its relationship with job satisfaction. When factors that increase professional autonomy are taken into account and attention is paid to the promotion of autonomy, it is possible to improve nurses’ job satisfaction. These issues cannot be solved at the unit level; investment is needed at the organizational and political levels. The results introduce nurses, managers, researchers, and stakeholders to improvements in the nursing practice environment toward an organizational culture where nurses may utilize their professional autonomy to its full potential.