Organizational Factors Contributing to Incivility at an Academic Medical Center and Systems-Based Solutions: A Qualitative Study

Abstract

PurposeA rise in incivility has been documented in medicine, with implications for patient care, organizational effectiveness, and costs. This study explored organizational factors that may contribute to incivility at one academic medical center and potential systems-level solutions to combat it.MethodThe authors completed semistructured individual interviews with full-time faculty members of the Department of Medicine (DOM) at the University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, with clinical appointments at six affiliated hospitals, between June and September 2016. They asked about participants’ experiences with incivility, potential contributing factors, and possible solutions. Two analysts independently coded a portion of the transcripts until a framework was developed with excellent agreement within the research team, as signified by the Kappa coefficient. A single coder completed analysis of the remaining transcripts.ResultsForty-nine interviews with physicians from all university ranks and academic position descriptions were completed. All participants had collegial relationships with colleagues but had observed, heard of, or been personally affected by uncivil behavior. Incivility occurred furtively, face-to-face, or online. The participants identified several organizational factors that bred incivility including physician nonemployee status in hospitals, silos within the DOM, poor leadership, a culture of silence, and the existence of power cliques. They offered many systems-level solutions to combat incivility through prevention, improved reporting, and clearer consequences.ConclusionsExisting strategies to combat incivility have focused on modifying individual behavior, but opportunities may exist to reduce incivility through a greater understanding of the role of health care organizations in shaping workplace culture.

Is Empowerment of Female Radiologists Still Needed? Findings of a Systematic Review

“…Moreover, women feel discriminated against and many are still victims of sexual harassment throughout their career [ 84 , 87 , 90 ]. In creating paths of change, tailored programs promoting respect in the workplace should be implemented internationally [ 132 , 133 ]. Further, to foster inclusive workplaces, family-supportive policies, flexible work opportunities, and programs ensuring a fair distribution of promotions should be encouraged [ 66 ].…”

Gender differences in reporting workplace violence: a qualitative analysis of administrative records of violent episodes experienced by healthcare workers in a large public Italian hospital

“…This approach is widely used in social science research35 and has been used to investigate HCWs’ perceptions of physical and verbal aggression 8 36 37. It has also been used, for example, to investigate the descriptions of violent behaviour provided by workers38 and perceptions of the organisational safety climate 39…”

Gotcha! Using Patient Safety Event Reports to Report People Rather Than Problems

“…The above vignette highlights that many perceived instances of unprofessional behavior between members of the health care team fall along a spectrum and may be more accurately categorized as incivility, microaggressions, or-as in this case-miscommunication. 4,5 The scenario also illustrates how safety event reporting can insidiously produce a culture of blame, as opposed to a culture of safety. In this Perspective, we describe what we believe is a growing problem in GME: the unintended consequences of using safety event reporting systems to report professionalism concerns.…”