Retrograde clay mineral reactions (i.e., reverse weathering), including glauconite formation, are first-order controls on element (re)cycling vs sequestration in modern and ancient marine sediments. Here, we report substantial K–Mg–Fe sequestration by glauconite formation in shallow marine settings from the Triassic to the Holocene, averaging 4 ± 3 mmol K·cm−²·kyr− 1, 4 ± 2 mmol Mg·cm−²·kyr− 1 and 10 ± 6 mmol Fe·cm−²·kyr− 1, which is ~ 2 orders of magnitude higher compared to deep-sea settings. Upscaling of glauconite abundances in shallow-water (< 200 m) environments predicts a global K–Mg–Fe uptake of ~ 0.05–0.06 Tmol K·yr− 1, ~ 0.04–0.06 Tmol Mg·yr− 1 and ~ 0.11–0.14 Tmol Fe·yr− 1. We conclude that authigenic clay elemental uptake had a large impact on the global marine K, Mg and Fe cycles throughout Earth`s history, in particular during ‘greenhouse’ periods with sea level highstand. Quantifying authigenic clay formation is key for better understanding past and present geochemical cycling in marine sediments.