“…Conversely, Mumpton and Roy [45] did not synthesize coffinite but uraninite and quartz and suggested coffinite may be metastable. Robit-Pointeau [41,46] suggested that (i) either the domain of thermodynamic stability of coffinite occurs in a narrow Eh/pH range, which would be different from the one predicted by the selected thermodynamic data [9], (ii) and/or coffinite precipitation is a kinetically controlled process and requires an unidentified precursor that could involve organic matter as reported from the uranium deposit [10,47,48]. Other coffinite synthesis protocols based on hydrothermal [49,50,7] or dry methods [51,52] are mentioned in the literature.…”