“…Subsequently, a series of acceptor/donor co-doped TiO 2 materials were widely investigated, involving trivalent acceptors and other acceptors. For instance, acceptor dopants (A + , B 2+ , C 3+ ), isovalent dopant (I 4+ ), and donor dopants (D 5+ ) (A = Ag or Li, 10,11 B = Mg, Zn, Sr, Cu or Ca, 12–15 C = Al, Sm, Bi, Fe, In, Dy, Ga, Gd, Yb, or Sc, 16–20 I = Zr, 21 and D = Nb 5+ , Sb 5+ , and Ta 5+ (ref. 1 and 22–26)).…”