Antiseptics are widely used in oral healthcare to prevent or treat oral diseases, such as gingivitis and periodontitis. However, the incidence of bacteria being tolerant to standard antiseptics has sharply increased over the last few years. This stresses the urgency for surveillance against tolerant organisms, as well as the discovery of novel antimicrobials. Traditionally, susceptibility to antimicrobials is assessed by broth micro-dilution or disc diffusion assays, both of which are time-consuming, labor-intensive and provide limited information on the mode of action of the antimicrobials. The above-mentioned limitations highlight the need for the development of new methods to monitor and further understand antimicrobial susceptibility. Here, we used real-time flow cytometry, combined with membrane permeability staining, as a quick and sensitive technology to study the quantitative and qualitative response of two oral pathobionts to different concentrations of chlorhexidine, cetylpyridinium chloride or triclosan. Apart from the real-time monitoring of cell damage, we further applied a phenotypic fingerprint method to differentiate between the bacterial subpopulations that arose due to treatment. We quantified the pathobiont damage rate of different antiseptics at different concentrations within 15 minutes of exposure and identified the conditions under which the bacteria were most susceptible. Moreover, we detected species-specific and treatment-specific phenotypic subpopulations. This proves that real-time flow cytometry can provide information on the susceptibility of different microorganisms in a short time frame while differentiating between antiseptics and thus could be a valuable tool in the discovery of novel antimicrobial compounds while at the same time deciphering their mode of action.