Outsourcing Regulation: How Insurance Reduces Moral Hazard

Abstract

This article explores the potential value of insurance as a substitute for government regulation of safety. Successful regulation of behavior requires information in setting standards, licensing conduct, verifying outcomes, and assessing remedies. In some areas, the private insurance sector has technological advantages in collecting and administering the information relevant to setting standards, and could outperform the government in creating incentives for optimal behavior. The paper explores several areas in which regulation and other government-oriented forms of control are replaced by private insurance schemes. The role of the law diminishes to the administration of simple rules of absolute liability or of no liability, and affected parties turn to insurers for both risk coverage and safety instructions. The paper illustrates the existing role of regulation-through-insurance in various areas of risky activity, and then explores its potential application in additional, yet unutilized, areas: (1) consumer protection; (2) food safety; and (3) financial statements. University of Chicago and University of Michigan, respectively. Helpful comments were provided by

Legal Intermediaries: How Insurance Companies Construct the Meaning of Compliance with Antidiscrimination Laws

“…From a policy standpoint, this study raises important questions about the role of insurance in regulating employer and employee relationships. While prior research highlights how insurance acts as a form of social control on society (Abraham 2013;Ben-Shahar and Logue 2012;Baker and Griffith 2010;Baker and Simon 2002), important questions remain: Should insurers regulate employer behavior? If so, how should that authority be exercised?…”

“…Empirical studies in the past twenty years reveal how the insurance industry plays an active role in constructing the meaning of risk and responsibility in different segments of society. Through policy language, pricing, and risk‐management services, liability insurance companies engage in loss prevention and regulate the behavior of actors and organizations (Abraham ; Ben‐Shahar and Logue ; Baker and Griffith ; Baker ; Ericson, Doyle, and Barry ; Heimer ). Insurance‐as‐governance studies highlight how insurers manage moral hazard in property and fidelity relationships (Heimer ), govern security in the home (O'Malley ), impact the motion picture industry in the United States (Hubbart ), and influence risk‐management approaches toward campus drinking (Simon ).…”

Data Breach, Privacy, and Cyber Insurance: How Insurance Companies Act as “Compliance Managers” for Businesses

“…Consistent with the global turn away from command-and-control regulation and toward more public-private partnerships and self-regulation, insurance scholars are increasingly discussing the role of private insurance as a form of regulation over individuals and organizations (Ben-Shahar and Logue 2012; Talesh 2015b). Insurance policies often take the form of private legislation or regulation through a wide variety of exclusions and conditions.…”

Insurance and the Law

“…Thus, insurance is able to regulate even acts within the home or business, where traditionally individuals have been free from interference (O'Malley, 1991;Baker, 2010;Ben-Shahar and Logue, 2012). The state engages in the regulation of its citizenry by setting eligibility requirements and benefit levels for social insurance.…”