Uterine leiomyoma should be considered when a female patient reports symptoms of abdominal pressure and abnormal vaginal bleeding. However, the symptoms of a uterine leiomyoma are vast and overlap with other possible diseases that are difficult to distinguish even with imaging studies. This is why it is important for physicians and healthcare providers to keep an open mind and have a broad differential diagnosis.In this case study, we present a 61-year-old postmenopausal female patient who presented to the emergency department with complaints of pelvic and abdominal pain, as well as vomiting and diarrhea. She was admitted for observation. A complete blood count (CBC), comprehensive metabolic panel (CMP), and urinalysis revealed no abnormalities; a pelvic ultrasound and CT scan reported possible adnexal torsion. The patient remained stable and the pain had subsided when she was seen the next morning by her gynecologist (GYN) who discharged her to follow-up in the office. Subsequent examinations that aided in the diagnosis included, but were not limited to pelvic and transvaginal ultrasounds, an abdominal and pelvic CT, and a pelvic MRI. In this case, the MRI revealed an 11-cm mass that could represent a torsioned pedunculated necrotic fibroid originating from the uterus. Radiology recommended surgical removal. Upon removal and review of the pathology of the mass, it was revealed to be a torsioned, partially necrotic fibroma that had originated from the ovary and not from the uterus, as imaging had originally suggested.