Overcoming barriers to recruiting ethnic minorities to mental health research: a typology of recruitment strategies

Abstract

BackgroundThe ethnic minority population in developed countries is increasing over time. These groups are at higher risk of mental illness and demonstrate lower participation in research. Published evidence suggests that multiple factors like stigma, lack of trust, differences in explanatory models, logistical issues and lack of culturally aware researchers act as barriers to ethnic minority recruitment into mental health research. To reduce inequalities in participation, there is a need to devise innovative and culturally sensitive recruitment strategies. It is important that researchers share their experience of employing these strategies so that ethnic minority participation can be facilitated.MethodsWe previously published a systematic review of barriers to recruiting ethnic minority participants into mental health research. The nine papers included in our prior review formed the basis for developing a typology of barriers to recruiting ethnic minorities into mental health research. This typology identified 33 barriers, described under five themes. We further extracted data on the strategies used to overcome these recruitment barriers, as described in the included studies.ResultsThe strategies employed by the authors could be matched to all but two barriers (psychopathology/substance misuse and limited resource availability). There was evidence that multiple strategies were employed, and that these depended upon the population, clinical set-up and resources available.ConclusionsThis typology of strategies to overcome barriers to recruiting ethnic minorities provides guidance on achieving higher rates of recruitment. It is important that researchers plan to deploy these strategies well in advance of initiating recruitment. Whilst adopting these strategies, the authors have not been able to quantify the positive impact of these strategies on recruitment. The typology should encourage researchers to employ these strategies in future research, refine them further and quantitatively evaluate their impact.

eHealth and mHealth Interventions for Ethnic Minority and Historically Underserved Populations in Developed Countries: an Umbrella Review

“…Five out of six of the SRs (SR1, SR2, SR3, SR4, SR6) reported improvements in participant physical health or self-care management skills, while only three SRs (SR1, SR5, SR6) reported improvement in a few psychosocial and mental health outcomes. This is in accordance with the challenges associated with recruiting minority populations for clinical trials or for mental health research, as found by Mason et al (2003) as well as Waheed et al (2015). Our analysis suggests that there is evidence supporting the effectiveness of web-based interventions improving ethnic minority and historically underserved community's health, ranging from weight management, asthma and diabetes knowledge and medical adherence.…”

A Review of Technology-Based Youth and Family-Focused Interventions

“…In most of the studies, implementers provided the required devices to any participants who lacked access to allow for study participation but that just begs the question. Access is improving, but individuals living in low SES neighborhoods still experiences lower rates of Internet connectivity (Fairlie 2005; Waheed et al 2015). …”

‘I accept my son for who he is – he has incredible character and personality’: fathers’ positive experiences of parenting children with autism

“…Ferguson (2002) argued that since both family and disability are culturally constructed, the ways in which mothers and fathers from differing cultural backgrounds experience and make sense of disability will vary considerably. Waheed et al (2015) identified 33 barriers to recruiting participants from ethnic minority groups to mental health research studies which they categorised in relation to five themes, namely: participant related barriers; practical issues; family/community related; health service related and research process related. They subsequently developed a typology of recruitment strategies aimed at overcoming these specific barriers, including for example, the planning of outreach activities in target communities and engaging the services of a "culturally competent" insider to facilitate access.…”