Locoregional recurrence negatively impacts both long-term survival and quality of life for a number of malignancies. For appropriate-risk patients with an isolated, resectable local recurrence, surgery represents the only potentially curative therapy. However, oncologic outcomes remain inferior for patients with locally recurrent disease even after macroscopically complete resection. Unfortunately, these operations are often extensive with significant perioperative morbidity and mortality. This review highlights selected malignancies (mesothelioma, sarcoma, lung cancer, breast cancer, rectal cancer, peritoneal surface malignancies) in which surgical resection is a key treatment modality and where local recurrence plays a significant role in overall oncologic outcome with regards to survival and quality of life. For each type of cancer, the current, state-of-the-art treatment strategies and their outcomes are assessed. The need for additional therapeutic options is presented given the limitations of the current standard therapies. New and emerging treatment modalities, including polymer films and nanoparticles, are highlighted as potential future solutions for both prevention and treatment of locally recurrent cancers. Finally, we identify additional clinical and research opportunities, and propose future research strategies based on the varying patterns of local recurrence among the different cancers.