Overestimating women’s representation in medicine: a survey of medical professionals’ estimates and their(un)willingness to support gender equality initiatives

Abstract

ObjectiveAmidst growing numbers of women in certain areas of medicine (eg, general practice/primary care), yet their continued under-representation in others (eg, surgical specialties), this study examines (1) whether medical professionals mistakenly infer that women are now broadly well represented, overestimating women’s true representation in several different areas and roles; and (2) whether this overestimation of women’s representation predicts decreased support for gender equality initiatives in the field, in conjunction with one’s own gender.DesignCross-sectional survey.SettingUK-based medical field.Participants425 UK medical consultants/general practitioners and trainees (ST/CT1+/SHO/Registrar); 47% were female.Main outcome measuresEstimates of women’s representation in different areas/roles within medicine, examined as a composite estimate and individually; and a multi-item measure of support for gender-based initiatives in medicine.ResultsMedical professionals tended to overestimate women’s true representation in several different areas of medicine (general practice, medical specialties, surgical specialties) and in various roles (consultants/general practitioners, trainees, medical school graduates). Moreover, these erroneous estimates predicted a decreased willingness to support gender-based initiatives, particularly among men in the field: composite overestimation*respondent gender interaction, B=−0.04, 95% CI −0.07 to −0.01, p=0.01. Specifically, while female respondents’ (over)estimates were unrelated to their level of support (B=0.00, 95% CI −0.02 to 0.02, p=0.92), male respondents’ tendency to overestimate the proportion of women in medicine predicted lower support for gender-based initiatives (B=−0.04, 95% CI −0.06 to −0.02, p<0.001).ConclusionsWhile some progress has been made in gender representation in the medical field, this research illustrates that there are still barriers to gender equality efforts and identifies who within the field is focally maintaining these barriers. It is those individuals (particularly men) who overestimate the true progress that has been made in women’s representation who are at highest risk of undermining it.

Addressing workplace gender inequality: Using the evidence to avoid common pitfalls

“…They can also help us understanding how workplace experiences can affect gendered workplace choices (e.g. Begeny et al, 2022 ; Meeussen et al, 2022 ; Morgenroth et al, 2022 ).…”

“…However, as Feenstra et al ( 2020 ) argue, rather than being seen as a personal problem that plagues individual women, it is critical to acknowledge the role that the social and organizational context plays in eliciting feelings of impostorism (see also Kark et al, 2022 ). Indeed, a series of studies by Begeny et al ( 2022 ) demonstrate that impostor feelings can be seen as is a direct response to how one is treated by others. In a longitudinal study, we showed that that experiencing fewer expressions of distinctive treatment, such as being asked for advice, resulted in a significant increase in impostor feelings over time.…”

“…Research also demonstrates that progress towards gender equality may be hampered by those who overestimate the rate of progress. A study by Begeny et al ( 2022 ) surveyed doctors in the United Kingdom who were asked to estimate the representation of women across a number of roles in the medical profession. Both male and female doctors consistently overestimated the number of women in medicine.…”

Women physicians in cardiovascular magnetic resonance: Past, present, and future

“…Even with this growing number of women in medical schools, it is interesting how medical professionals may mistakenly infer that women are now broadly well-represented, overestimating the true representation. The misperception could produce growing reservations or less support for gender equality initiatives and political support ( 26 ).…”

Scarlett McNally: International Women’s Day—and how institutions and individuals can reduce sexism in healthcare

“…There’s a triple whammy of negative perceptions, difficult structures (especially around child rearing), and a lack of support to undertake leadership roles. Many doctors don’t appreciate that women in medicine have a different experience—and they therefore don’t consider change to be necessary 8. Some of us in healthcare don’t realise how our own behaviour can be misinterpreted, nor how easy it is to change 9…”