Overtourism and online short-term rental platforms in Italian cities

Abstract

Although Italian cities have undergone several waves of touristification, concerns about overtourism have only recently become widespread. In the article, we suggest that the diffusion of short-term rental platforms is not merely a concomitant factor, but is crucial to understanding the how and where of contemporary overtourism. To this end we apply a fractal methodology to identify, map and compare those parts of the city that are most affected, and measure the pressure short-term rentals have on city centres as places of residence. By allowing the conversion of residential apartments into tourist accommodation, we argue, short term rentals contribute to the displacement of residents more directly than a generic process of gentrification or touristification. Second, platforms such as Airbnb not only contribute to increasing the accommodation capacity of urban areas, but radically change the morphology of the tourist city. The growing concerns about overtourism are not due to the rising number of tourists per se, but to their increasing penetration into the residential city. We suggest, therefore, that to conceive of overtourism merely as overcrowding is not only inadequate but counterproductive. Even though the depopulation of city centres is difficult to reverse, the coronavirus emergency is an opportunity to plan a different city where tourism coexists with other urban uses and functions.

Tourism, technology and ICT: a critical review of affordances and concessions

“…Even though hopes have been expressed that technology and ICT will make major contributions to advancing the SDGs, it appears that ICT tools are currently used to investigate and understand the very problems the ICT economy created in the first place (e.g. Celata & Romano, 2020;Peeters et al 2018). Even forward-looking discussions of ICT (Fennell, 2020;Han et al, 2018;McGrath et al, 2020) do not suggest transformative outcomes.…”

Urban tourism and population change: Gentrification in the age of mobilities

“…Firstly, our analysis will attempt to show that tourism activity in certain neighbourhoods causes population decline linked to a decrease of inhabited dwellings. Urban scholars have recently suggested that the prepandemic excessive growth of tourism and short‐term rentals involves a sharp wave of displacement of residents to such an extent that some areas are losing their residential base and tacitly becoming tourist clusters (Celata & Romano, 2020; Cocola‐Gant, 2016; Jover & Díaz‐Parra, 2019; Sequera & Nofre, 2018 and 2019). This outcome was also suggested by tourism scholars such as Law (2002) and Ap and Crompton (1993), who concluded that in mature tourist destinations, residents tend to move out of the community and therefore that population decrease may occur.…”

The Undisrupted Growth of the Airbnb Phenomenon between 2014–2020. The Touristification of European Cities before the COVID-19 Outbreak

“…Besides that, it seems to be indisputable that Italy has been the most damaged during the first wave of the pandemic in Europe. Indeed, the current crisis is the most perceptible in those cases where the tourism economy overwhelmed other sectors of the economy [58]. According to ENIT-the Italian national tourism agency-to the end of July, the international arrivals has dropped there by 90%.…”