Herein we present the case of a 78-year-old female who suffered a radial nerve injury following her third left shoulder arthroplasty. At first follow-up two and a half weeks following shoulder surgery, she presented with left arm weakness and profound, persistent hand weakness. This was diagnosed as complete radial nerve palsy. After three months, the patient still had no return of function. At that point, she became a candidate for tendon transfer surgery to remediate her complete radial nerve palsy. At six months post-arthroplasty, it was noted on exam that she unexpectedly regained weak wrist extension two weeks before her scheduled three tendon transfer surgery. The decision was made to proceed with a modified two tendon transfer procedure. Surgery is the most reliable treatment to restore function, but it must be tailored for each patient's specific needs. A current assessment of the patient's reconstructive needs must be performed to prevent overtreatment.