meso-Phenyldipyrromethene acetylacetonato copper(II) complexes [Cu(dpm-C6H4R)(acac)] (dpm-C6H4R = phenyl-substituted dipyrromethene, acac = acetylacetonato) with different substituents R at the phenyl moiety were synthesized. These substituents determine the mode of assembly into polymeric chains, namely, via hydrogen bonds, coordinative bonds, or covalent bonds (by immobilization on a polymer). Although the primary coordination sphere around the copper center is essentially identical for all complexes reported in this study (square-planar geometry with N2O2 coordination), subtle differences due to the different microenvironments have been observed in their structures, properties, and reactivity as probed by IR spectroscopy, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, magnetic measurements, thermal analyses, density functional theory calculations, and reaction with pyridine.