Palestinian Solidarity Action: The Dynamics of Politicized and Religious Identity Patterns Among Student Activists

Shadiqi, Muhammad Abdan; Muluk, Hamdi; Milla, Mirra Noor

doi:10.7454/hubs.asia.1140818

Cited by 7 publications

(8 citation statements)

References 51 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Our first criterion was that the studies should have included the measures of both social identification and participation in collective action variables. Some studies focusing on the relationship between shared social identity and collective action that took place between 2011 and 2020, were not included in this study, since they were either qualitative (e.g., Khazraee & Novak, 2018), or not digitally mediated (see Selvanathan & Lickel, 2019;Shadiqi et al, 2018).…”

Section: Methods Inclusion Criteria and Literature Searchmentioning

confidence: 99%

Social identification and collective action participation in the internet age: A meta-analysis

et al. 2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Since the digitally-mediated large-scale protests took place all over the world, the role of social identities in collective actions has become the center of academic attention. Some scholars have claimed that interpersonal or individual reasons have become more important than collective identifications in participating digitally-mediated collective actions. To answer the question that whether social identification has lost its centrality in collective actions in the Internet age, we conducted a meta-analysis of 46 studies (N = 18,242) which examined digitally-mediated collective actions across the world reported between January 2011 and January 2020. We focused on the relationship between social identification and collective action, and the possible moderator effects of group type to be identified (emergent vs. pre-existing group), participation type (actual behavior vs. intention), and WEIRDness of the sample. The analyses showed a moderate to strong relationship between social identification and participation in digitally-mediated collective actions, while group type was the only significant moderator. Accordingly, the relationship between identification with emergent groups and collective action participation was much stronger compared to the relationship between identification with pre-existing groups and collective action participation. We discussed the theoretical implications of the results emphasized the basic dynamics of collective actions.

show abstract

Section: Methods Inclusion Criteria and Literature Searchmentioning

confidence: 99%

Social identification and collective action participation in the internet age: A meta-analysis

et al. 2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…We explored the role of religious identity in collective action, following the suggestion of Baysu and Phalet (2017). Shadiqi et al, (2018) found that Muslim identity does not directly explain the peaceful collective action in the Palestinian conflict context; instead, group efficacy was determined as one mediating factor between the two. Derived from there, we believe that religious identity could be another factor contributing to such action.…”

Section: Religious Identity In Collective Actionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Support for Palestinian among Indonesian Muslim: Religious identity and solidarity as reasons for e-petition signing

Shadiqi

Muluk

Milla

2020

PROUST

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

A petition is a form of collective action urging the government or a public entity to resolve a specific situation. There is inconsistency between previous research on whether religious or political identity is more likely to lead to radical or peaceful actions, especially in terms of how feelings of solidarity relate to religious-political issues. This study examines the reasons Indonesians signed e-petitions supporting Palestine. Data were collected from the comment sections of e-petitions supporting Palestine on change.org. In total, we analyzed 380 comments from 25 e-petitions using a qualitative approach. Using NVivo for thematic analysis, we found that the most recurring themes were moral violation, followed by independence for Palestine, solidarity, hatred as a negative emotion, and religious identity. Additionally, matrix nodes analysis showed identification with Islam was related to solidarity. These findings suggest that the similarity of religious identity in the two nations can be associated with solidarity as a reason for signing the e-petitions. We also discussed the association between moral violation and independence for Palestine as reasons for signing the e-petitions.

show abstract

“…Sekalipun demikian, studi ini menunjukkan bahwa tidak ada korelasi antara persepsi bawahan mengenai agama pemimpin dengan dukungan terhadap pemimpin (leader endorsement). Hasil ini sejalan dengan temuan penelitian sebelumnya, bahwa identitas agama tidak secara langsung memotivasi seseorang di dalam sebuah organisasi untuk berperilaku (Shadiqi, Muluk, & Milla, 2018). Temuan ini kemungkinan menggambarkan bahwa identitas agama dipandang sebagai aspek kehidupan pribadi individu, sehingga pada penelitian ini, terkait dengan teori identitas sosial, persepsi terhadap identitas agama pemimpin bukanlah faktor yang memengaruhi dukungan bawahan kepada pemimpin.…”

Section: Tabel 1 Means Standard Deviations and Correlationsunclassified

Anteseden leader endorsement: Perspektif teori identitas sosial

Nugraha

Samian

Riantoputra

2020

JPS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Salah satu kunci dari efektivitas kepemimpinan adalah bagaimana seorang pemimpin diterima dan didukung oleh bawahannya (leader endorsement). Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengidentifikasi faktor-faktor yang memengaruhi dukungan bawahan terhadap pemimpin berdasarkan teori identitas sosial. Artikel ini memiliki hipotesis bahwa prototipikalitas pemimpin (leader prototypicality) dan personal bases of power dari pemimpin (expert power dan referent power) memengaruhi dukungan bawahan terhadap pemimpinnya. Menggunakan online surveys kami berhasil mendapatkan partisipan sebanyak 135 karyawan dari berbagai perusahaan swasta di Indonesia. Reliabilitas masing-masing alat ukur yang digunakan berkisar antara 0,80 – 0,90. Hasil analisis menunjukkan bahwa: (1) leader prototypicality tidak signifikan memengaruhi leader endorsement (β = .124; p < .05); (2) leaders’ expert power (β = .767; p < .01) dan leaders’ referent power (β = .363; p < .01) signifikan memengaruhi leader endorsement. Faktor tersebut mampu memprediksi varian leader endorsement sebesar 78,3%, F(3.94) = 56.706, p < .01. Temuan penelitian ini dapat memberikan kontribusi terhadap perkembangan teori identitas sosial bahwa pada konteks perusahaan swasta, identitas sosial pemimpin bukan menjadi faktor yang menentukan terbentuknya dukungan terhadap pemimpin.

show abstract

Palestinian Solidarity Action: The Dynamics of Politicized and Religious Identity Patterns Among Student Activists

Cited by 7 publications

References 51 publications

Social identification and collective action participation in the internet age: A meta-analysis

Social identification and collective action participation in the internet age: A meta-analysis

Support for Palestinian among Indonesian Muslim: Religious identity and solidarity as reasons for e-petition signing

Anteseden leader endorsement: Perspektif teori identitas sosial

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About