This study assessed the hypothesis that popularity in adolescence takes on a twofold role, both marking high levels of concurrent psychosocial adaptation, but also predicting increases over time in both positive and negative behaviors sanctioned by peer norms. This hypothesis was tested with multi-method, longitudinal data obtained on a diverse community sample of 185 adolescents. Sociometric popularity data were examined in relation to data from interview-based assessments of attachment security and ego development, observations of mother-adolescent interactions, and repeated self-and peer-report assessments of delinquency and alcohol use. Results indicated that popular adolescents displayed higher concurrent levels of ego development, secure attachment and more adaptive interactions with mothers and best friends. Longitudinal analyses supported a "popularity-socialization" hypothesis, however, in which popular adolescents were more likely to increase in behaviors that receive approval in the peer group (e.g., minor levels of drug use and delinquency) and decrease in behaviors unlikely to be well-received by peers (e.g., hostile behavior with peers).
The Two Faces Of Adolescents' Success With Peers: Adolescent Popularity, Social Adaptation, and Deviant BehaviorAt no other stage of the lifespan is peer socialization as fraught with tension, ambiguity, and strain as during adolescence. Extrapolations from childhood research suggest that popularity in adolescence should be a positive marker of adaptation to be encouraged and promoted (Parker & Asher, 1987;Rubin, Bukowski, & Parker, 1998). Yet, adolescents who are popular, and hence well-socialized into their peer groups, would also appear vulnerable to being socialized into the increasing levels of delinquent and drug-using behavior that become normative in peer groups during this period. As compared to research in childhood, far less research has been conducted on popularity in adolescence. Yet, becoming popular is a prime goal for many adolescents and requires adaptation to a far broader and less supervised peer group than is found in the contained classrooms and geographically limited neighborhoods of childhood (Brown & Klute, 2003;Collins & Laursen, 2004). The potential dual role of popularity in adolescence--as both a marker of adaptation but also as a risk factor for increases in deviant behavior--has never previously been examined.Correspondence concerning this study should be sent to the first author at Department of Psychology, University of Virginia, Box 400400, Charlottesville, VA 22904-4400 (Email: allen@virginia.edu)..
NIH Public Access Author ManuscriptChild Dev. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2006 August 22.
Published in final edited form as:Child Dev. 2005 ; 76(3): 747-760.
NIH-PA Author ManuscriptNIH-PA Author Manuscript
NIH-PA Author ManuscriptSelf-report research has linked perceived acceptance by one's peers in adolescence to better academic performance and to lower levels of substance abuse (Diego, Field, & Sanders, 2003). Unfortu...