Parenting in 2 Worlds: Effects of a Culturally Adapted Intervention for Urban American Indians on Parenting Skills and Family Functioning

Abstract

Parenting in 2 Worlds (P2W) is a culturally grounded parenting intervention that addresses the distinctive social and cultural worlds of urban American Indian (AI) families. P2W was culturally adapted through community-based participatory research in three urban AI communities with diverse tribal backgrounds. This paper reports the immediate outcomes of P2W in a randomized controlled trial, utilizing data from 575 parents of AI children (ages 10–17). Parents were assigned to P2W or to the comparison group, an informational family health curriculum, Healthy Families in 2 Worlds (HF2W). Both the P2W and HF2W curricula consisted of 10 workshops delivered weekly by AI community facilitators. Pretests were administered at the first workshop and a post-test at the last workshop. Tests of the efficacy of P2W versus HF2W on parenting skills and family functioning were analyzed with pairwise t-tests, within intervention type, and by baseline adjusted path models using FIML estimation in Mplus. Intervention effect sizes were estimated with Cohen’s d. Participants in P2W reported significant improvements in parental agency, parenting practices, supervision and family cohesion, and decreases in discipline problems and parent-child conflict. Compared to HF2W, P2W participants reported significantly larger increases in parental self-agency and positive parenting practices, and fewer child discipline problems. Most of these desired program effects for P2W approached medium size. Culturally adapted parenting interventions like P2W can effectively strengthen parenting practices and family functioning among urban AI families and help address their widespread need for targeted, culturally grounded programs.

Cultural Adaptation of Group Parenting Programs: Review of the Literature and Recommendations for Best Practices

“…Eight programs discussed changes to the delivery methods of the original program in order to address cultural differences (Table 3). These types of changes included re‐organizing sessions into weekly 2‐hour lunchtime sessions over 5 weeks rather than weekly 1‐hour lunchtime sessions over 8 weeks (Bogart et al., 2013), adapting workshop lessons to introduce and approach topics holistically and experientially rather than presenting material as a set of elements or steps to be assembled into a whole (Kulis et al., 2016), and replacing the use of puppets, which require the children to be comfortable taking risks and performing in front of peers, with role plays modeled by facilitators (Marek, Brock, & Sullivan, 2006).…”

Predictors of Substance Use Latent Classes Among American Indian Youth Attending Schools On or Near Reservations

“…14 Others found that AI parents can be more responsible for providing support and encouragement, while extended families assume the role of discipline, such as communicating dangers of substance use. 38 We asked specifically about parent communication, which may have obscured effects due to extended family communications.…”

Risk and Resilience Among Families in Urban AI/AN Communities: the Role of Young Adults

“…There is, of course, much diversity in family life across the AI/AN population. For example, AI/AN families living on reservations are more likely to rely on extended family (e.g., multiple generations living in one household) [11], or other tribal relations [12]) for practical purposes (e.g., economic support, caregiving) and moral/spiritual guidance [13]. On reservations, the extended family also plays a role in reinforcing cultural beliefs and values [14].…”