A dust particle immersed in a glow-discharge plasma has long been known to have a charge that is negative, while the plasma is powered. However, in the afterglow, following the stopping of the plasma power, a large positive charge can collect on the particle, as was shown recently for particles in a cathodic sheath. While that outcome of positive charging in the afterglow may be common, an experiment reported here reveals that the opposite outcome is also possible: a particle can develop a negative charge in the afterglow, if the plasma had previously been operated with a modulated power. Before stopping the plasma power off altogether, in a run with power modulated at a low duty cycle of 4.5%, the particle’s residual charge was negative, but it was positive in a control run without modulation. This result points to a way of controlling the charge of dust particles in a decaying plasma, which can be useful for mitigating defects in semiconductor manufacturing.