This work documents the first account of advanced mechanical properties of six commercial lipsticks, some of which serve as market leads. We systematically studied their nonlinear viscoelastic properties under large amplitude oscillatory shear deformations. At large strains, all lipsticks showed intercycle strain softening, the extent of which initially depended on the prototype in the nonlinear regime. This behavior, markedly, was absent after the crossover of the dynamic moduli. Parameters obtained from the strain amplitude sweeps, i.e., the intrinsic elastic modulus and the stress maximum, demonstrated distinct prototype dependence. The Lissajous plots and the dimensionless nonlinear indices were determined using the MITlaos software. They showed intracycle elastic strain stiffening and viscous shear thinning. The angular oscillation frequency directly influenced the linear viscoelastic measures of all the benchmark lipsticks, and the nonlinear properties of only a few benchmark ones. The current study generates standard nonlinear rheology data that can be associated with the lipstick sensory attributes and typical tribological parameters. This may serve as an effective way to examine the transition from the initial spreading to the post-application sensation.