Passive, Silent and Revolutionary: The ‘Arab Spring’ Revisited

Abstract

To counter the trend toward mechanization of research and aridity of critical analysis, this article makes a case for an interdisciplinary quest. To borrow Felix Guattari and Gilles Deleuze’s phrase, we are convinced that ‘everything is political, but every politics is simultaneously a macropolitics and a micropolitics.’ With an eye to open-ended research questions, this article attempts to build a body of theoretical, political and anthropological considerations, which, it is hoped, could function as a case of enquiry into the mechanics of power, revolt and revolution. The objective is to draw comparative and phenomenological lines between the events of the 2011 ‘Arab Spring,’ in its local ecologies of protest, with its global reverberations as materialized in the slogans, acts and ideals of Greek and Spanish Indignados and the UK and US occupy movements. In order to do so, it proposes to clarify terminological ambiguities and to bring into the analytical scenario new subjects, new means and new connections. The article resolves to lay the ground for a scholarship of silence, by which the set of unheard voices, hidden actions and defiant tactics of the ordinary, through extraordinary people, find place in the interpretation of phenomena such as revolts and revolutions.

‘Westoxication’ and resistance: the politics of dance in Iran #dancingisnotacrime

“…7 In a podcast series titled, 'Choreographing Transnational Maternities: As Brownlee and Ghiabi have suggested, interpretations offered by mainstream Anglo-American and European sources continue to reproduce classical Orientalist tropes. 9 In these accounts, there is an invariable emphasis on gender, religion and nationality as markers of identity, with Islam as the uniquely determining force behind the regime's reactionary policies.…”

Awakening from the sleep-walking society: Crisis, detachment and the real in prepper awakening narratives

“…These collective awakenings are tied to struggles for wider change, the restructuring of institutions and redefinition of collective social goals. Brownlee and Ghiabi (2016), however, question this agential link in the context of the so-called ‘Arab Awakening,’ a term first used by George Antonius in his famous book (1938). Awakening, they argue, implies a pre-existing lack of agency or absence of political being, something that was not there previously or existed only latently in those ‘previously asleep’.…”

“…Billaud (2021: 4705) argues that this reinforces a commonly held idea that ‘political consciousness emerges only during historical trigger events or through specific modes of socialization,’ overlooking the ‘ordinary’ or ‘slow activism’ of subaltern groups. When attributed rather than self-adopted, the language of awakening signals a change in perception of the racialized Other, from passive and weak to (dangerously) active (Brownlee and Ghiabi, 2016). Claims of passivity and weakness in the ‘sleeping’ society were notoriously expressed in the Nazi party anthem ‘Germany Awake’ (‘Deutschland Erwache!’).…”

“…As 'awakening' expanded from religious into wider cultural and political spheres, it retained connotations of ideological conversion and personal transformation (Schneider-Mayerson, 2015). It now names both individual and collective moments of transition to heighted awareness and agency across spiritual (Cameron, 2013), religious (Clark, 1929), political (Brownlee andGiabi, 2016), environmental (Schneider-Mayerson, 2015), cultural and sexual fields. Awakening attains meaning through differentiation from a cluster of related concepts: 'conversion', 'enlightenment', 'revolution' 'renaissance' and 'resurgence'; and in tension with opposing concepts, including brainwashing and false consciousness.…”

COVID-19 outbreak, disruption of dental education, and the role of teledentistry

“…13 In 2011, Egypt faced the Arab Spring due to political unrest in the country. 14 This resulted in the closure of dental schools and many Malaysian dental students who were studying there were called back by their government. 15 These students upon their return faced problems like safe return, the difference in the curriculum, high tuition costs, and credit transfer.…”